KIOS-FM

For Many Fire Evacuees, There's Still No Going Back To Paradise

Feb 1, 2019
Originally published on February 1, 2019 9:07 pm

Paradise, Calif., the northern California town nestled in a pine cloaked ridge in the Sierra Foothills, had a population of about 25,000 until it was almost entirely wiped out by the Camp Fire nearly three months ago. It was the deadliest, most destructive wildfire in the U.S. in more than a century. Now, despite a massive effort to clean up, restore power and make plans to rebuild, the town remains largely uninhabitable.

There are still burned out cars, pickups and school buses lining its roads. Neighborhoods remain unrecognizable to even longtime residents. There's ash and toxic debris everywhere.

"We've been staring at these same businesses and these same homes, burned down in our neighborhoods for over two months," says Duane Crowder, a volunteer who's coordinating disaster relief. "Nothing has been done with them."

Duane Crowder is coordinating disaster relief at the Magalia Baptist Church, where 300-600 people show up each day for free meals.
Kirk Siegler / NPR

Nevertheless, all around Paradise, utility crews are putting power lines back up on the windy one-way-in, one-way-out streets and cul-de-sacs where lot after lot is burned out. Gas lines and phone service are also being restored. But for whom? Some former residents and local leaders are starting to question whether anyone is really going to live here anytime soon.

"Paradise will probably not rebuild for a decade," Crowder says.

The monumental task of removing that debris is beginning this week in earnest, a job that could take well over a year. Disaster response officials say it's on a scale not seen in this country since the Sept. 11 attacks.

Even after that, rebuilding is no guarantee for a lot of people.

Crowder's father is the pastor at the Magalia Baptist Church, which did not burn. After the fire, the family transformed the facility into an aid station, a lifeline for up to 600 people per day. They come for free meals, pick up donated clothes, shoes. Spend just a few minutes there, and it's remarkable how fast the cases of bottled water get distributed from large pallets that Crowder can't get enough of. Paradise's water isn't safe to drink. Benzenes from burning plastics, soot and ash seeped into the town's water supply.

Homes leveled by the Camp Fire line the Ridgewood Mobile Home Park retirement community in Paradise, Calif., seen last December.
Noah Berger / AP

Most of the people who are still here have few other options but to live in their cars or a camper on their burned out property. A lot of people who could leave have left.

"People have just said you know what, nuts to it, we're out of here, there's not going to be anything here," Crowder says. "As the time goes on people start to realize, how much time this is going to take."

No going back

Linda Oslin, 73, and her husband Bob, who's 85, lost their home in Paradise. They had lived there since 1972.

They've been staying with friends in a little town down in the valley ever since. Just along one small country lane, there are at least three other families doubling up in homes, in similar states of limbo.

The couple has already decided they won't rebuild. They don't want to go back. One of the biggest concerns is the toxicity. They were avid gardeners, and if it's going to take more than a year just to clear the lots, they say, it's anybody's guess when crews will get around to theirs. No one can even start planning to rebuild until the debris is removed, and the government has certified the sites are safe.

"And then to get a contractor and they're going to be rebuilding, what, 14,000 homes," Bob says. "At my age, I don't have years."

The Oslins watched as it went from a quiet, country town to a commuter city built out into the woods. It was cheaper — a haven for retirees on fixed incomes.

But the Oslins, and a lot of other people, were traumatized by the fire.

"We just don't want to go back up there," Bob says. "I don't know if I could sleep well if I woke up at two o'clock in the morning and heard the wind blowing, 40 miles and it's 80 degrees out, I'd lay there just wide awake thinking, 'oh boy.'"

They recently bought a new house in nearby Oroville.

Rebuilding an entire city

The Camp Fire has again exposed the high risk of living in overgrown forests now prone to even more severe wildfires due to climate change. The aftermath is leading some to wonder whether this country's immediate response to natural disasters, the rush to rebuild and put everything back how it was, is the right thing to do.

Local leaders like Ed Mayer, for instance, say they've been puzzled by the apparent rush by utility crews to reinstall a lot of the infrastructure in Paradise.

"Their charge, given their funding streams, is to rebuild what was there, whether that makes sense or not," says Mayer, the executive director of the Housing Authority for Butte County.

It is a chicken-and-egg dilemma, though: how do you begin to even recover from a disaster if there's no infrastructure to support it? For most, rebuilding is so far off in the future that Mayer is doing all he can to help people relocate, mostly out of state. There was already a severe housing shortage here before the fire.

For many in Paradise, the reality is starting to sink in that it could take years to recover let alone rebuild.
Kirk Siegler / NPR

"We see these populations coming out of Paradise, they want to stay with their community, they've been here for decades," he says. "But really, that's not an option."

Not an option right now for a place that is basically a skeleton — they're trucking in water to make coffee at Starbucks, the hospital is shuttered, the Safeway is rubble. And upwards of one million burnt trees need to be cut and hauled away

There's so much work to be done, some here question whether the town should even be reopened to the general public at this point. At the baptist church, Duane Crowder figures it's probably too soon to even talk about rebuilding. No one here has ever seen anything like this before.

"How do you rebuild an entire city from the ground up? We don't know," Crowder says. "How long does it take? We don't know."

Copyright 2019 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

ARI SHAPIRO, HOST:

Now to California, where a massive cleanup is getting underway in and around the town of Paradise, which was nearly wiped out by a deadly wildfire last fall. Disaster response officials say the country has not seen a toxic debris cleanup of this scale since 9/11. Just cleaning up thousands of destroyed homes and businesses could take more than a year. And as NPR's Kirk Siegler reports, rebuilding after the cleanup isn't guaranteed for a lot of people.

KIRK SIEGLER, BYLINE: I'm on what was a cul-de-sac near Paradise, and everything around me is reduced to ash and rubble. There's a burned-out car over here. And it still smells like smoke. But right behind me, I can see a utility crew. And they're reinstalling all the telephone lines from burned-out property to burned-out property. Those phone lines and a lot of power and gas lines are going back up around here, but for whom? Who's going to really live here anytime soon?

DUANE CROWDER: Paradise will probably not see rebuild for a decade.

SIEGLER: Duane Crowder is coordinating disaster relief at this local Baptist church. He's the son of the pastor.

CROWDER: As we look around, I mean, we've been staring at these same businesses and these same homes burned down in our neighborhoods for over two months. We've just been standing here in the parking lot staring at them. Nothing has been done with them.

SIEGLER: The church did not burn, and it's been transformed into an aid station. It's a lifeline for up to 600 people some days. They come for free meals, pick up donated clothes and shoes. As we talk, a man who looks exhausted pulls up in a worn sedan. He gratefully takes a few cases of bottled water.

UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #1: Oh, thank you very much. Yeah. So really appreciate it.

SIEGLER: Paradise's water isn't safe to drink. Benzenes from burning plastic, soot and ash seeped into the town's water supply.

UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #2: When you get hungry, breakfast and lunch every day.

UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #1: Oh, yeah. I appreciate it. I have come a couple times.

SIEGLER: Most of the people who are still here have few other options but to live in their cars or a camper on their burned-out property. A lot of people have left.

CROWDER: People have just said, you know what? Nuts to it. We're out of here. You know, there's not going to be anything here. And as the time goes on, people start to realize how much time this is going to take.

LINDA OSLIN: I mean, my friends are scattered all over the country.

SIEGLER: Seventy-three-year-old Linda Oslin and her husband Bob, who's 85, lost their home.

OSLIN: If they were thinking about going to live near family, that was a decision that was made for them. And they're gone.

SIEGLER: The Oslins have been staying with friends in a little town in the Valley ever since. They don't want to go back.

OSLIN: The first thing I think of is the toxicity.

BOB: They figure - what? - it's going to take a year to clear those lots. And who knows when they're going to get around to ours? And then to get a contractor. And they're going to be rebuilding - what? - 14 - 17,000 homes. At my age, I don't have years, you know.

SIEGLER: The Oslins lived in Paradise since 1972, watching as it went from a quiet country town to a commuter city built out into the woods. It was cheaper. It's a haven for retirees on fixed incomes. But the Oslins and a lot of other people were traumatized by the fire.

BOB: And we just don't want to go back up there. I don't know if I can sleep well in the middle of the summer if I woke up at 2 o'clock in the morning and heard the wind blowing 40 miles an hour and it's 80 degrees out. I'd lay there just wide awake thinking, oh, boy.

SIEGLER: The Camp Fire has again exposed the high risk of living in overgrown forests now prone to even more severe wildfires due to climate change. Its aftermath is also leading some to wonder whether our immediate response to disasters, the rush to rebuild and put everything back how it was is the right thing to do. Ed Mayer runs the housing authority of Butte County.

ED MAYER: We see these populations coming out of Paradise. They want to stay here. They want to stay with their community. They've been here for decades. But really, that's not an option.

SIEGLER: Not an option right now for a place that already had a housing shortage and is now basically a skeleton. They're trucking in water to make coffee at Starbucks. The hospital is shuttered. The Safeway is rubble. And upwards of a million burnt trees need to be cut and hauled away.

(CROSSTALK)

SIEGLER: At the church, Dwayne Crowder told me it's probably too soon to even talk about rebuilding. No one here has ever seen anything like this before.

CROWDER: How do you rebuild an entire city from the ground up? We don't know. How long does it take? We don't know.

SIEGLER: Should it be rebuilt?

CROWDER: You know, probably.

SIEGLER: A question that may continue to get debated as the recovery wears on. Kirk Siegler, NPR News, Paradise, Calif.

(SOUNDBITE OF DYALLA'S "SUNDOWN") Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.